Actually it's probably more relevant here cause I'm debating the use of transformation points for menagerie, outside input is welcome.
QUOTE
What matters is the roleplaying. The stats and numbers and rules in the books only serve to quantify what happens in the roleplaying experience.
It's easy to fall back on the Golden Rule for any rules abuse, you need to think of the consequences of changes you make to the game.
QUOTE
Besides, no ST would allow a character's level 5 Menagerie to have it's own high-level Menagerie with it's own high-level Menagerie and so on.
I was using an extreme example to point out the broken system. Its alright then to have a 5 dot menagerie creature that has a 5 dot device, 5 dot sanctum, 5 dot reputation and 6 dot ressources?
I wouldn't have a problem with Asura if he was played by another player. As is he's being used as an extension of the character, a tool, a gizmo, his faithful pet.
QUOTE
Your cinematographer friend is just that...a good friend. Allies are people who are allied with you on the same mission. Not just friends but partners-in-crime, bosom buddies, etc. If you and your friend had thrown in lots as business partners or were united in some purpose you would be allies.
Actually he comes to me for legal and business advice on his films all the time, intellectual property is my specialty. What are "bosom buddies" if not friends since birth? The point is that you don't control your friends. By definition, in my mind at least, that's not a friend or ally. That's not the relationship between Li and Asura.
QUOTE
Although it may have seemed to others that the introduction was a show of Lis dominance, it was actually just part of the performance. By seeming to "control" the tiger Li adds to his persona AND used the scene to test others reactions...Its all part of the show folks. In actuallity Asura was in on the whole act willingly...If people think he's just a tiger or menagerie they will underestimate him.
You've also carefully framed the dominant relationship in the background.
QUOTE
Besides, although he may have not entirely succeeded in coming up with a rules mechanism to represent Asura's abilities and motives, he definitely succeeded in creating an interesting sidekick and foil to his character. At this point, I would be sincerely sorry to see the big cat leave the game, because I'm interested to see how SkyLion and Blue are going to play him. Besides, if BlueNinja is happy with SkyLion's background assignments, I certainly am too.
I'd let the cat stay as is, I'd remove the cat's backgrounds (and maybe spend those transformation points on attributes or knacks)
QUOTE
Can we see the back of this argument soon? I'm not saying anything as a moderator because everyone's been so polite about it, but I think it's a little late to be talking about it now that the game has started. 13 Transformation points is plenty, and I think with four players, none of us is going to be overshadowed by any one player character.
I'm arguing for future games as well, this rule simply makes no sense to me. Its essentially a loophole for the character allowing the use of 26 transformation points or more through careful planning. I'd have no qualms at all if Asura was another PC. Right now its a carefully planned servant. It follows "willingly because of X and Y" and the character can use the menagerie's background as if they were its own, because the character is the mentor...Why does the mentor enhancement proposed by BN only allow the distribution of mentor points to other backgrounds to a maximum of 4 when menagerie and ally allows unlimited backgrounds useable by the character? I'm okay with allowing Skylion keep Asura with no changes, but I disagree with the rule in and of itself, it shouldn't be used as is.
QUOTE
I think SkyLion started with the idea of Asura as a character and tried to convert him into the Adventure! rules, instead of thinking of ways to exploit the rules and coming up with character-based pretenses.
No doubt...but at some point the reasoning shifted to how can this best favor my character:
QUOTE
From his vast Sanctum, Asura has brought an honor guard of 3 of his most powerful "Generals." They understand their role in the show and contribute to its mystique greatly. Given Li's relationship with Asura and his Animal Handling skills regardless, they defer to him as well, but because Asura says so! Remember that even though the other tigers are Asuras menagerie, Li IS Asura's mentor and the cat his loyal folllower. No matter what though they will be survivors together...
Why not just give Asura a knack called "Control Tigers" or "Communicate to tigers" which he uses during shows? Does it really have to be a menagerie of its own?
Anyway...
<span style='color:gray'>I failed to make the chess team because of my height. <br />- Woody Allen<br /><br />They that would give up essential liberty for a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.<br />- Benjamin Franklin <br /></span>