Jump to content

Mutants & Masterminds - Mutants and Masterminds 3rd Edition


Recommended Posts

I've not been playing long enough for a laundry list but the two things that stand out are:

Kibosh or fix the Jack of All Trades feat. Its stupid broken as it is.

Grappling could use some help, its a little overly complex given the way the rest of the combat rules are.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The system is a bit vulnerable to "one unlucky roll" syndrome when it comes to making Toughness saves. Two guys of equal point values and comparable power...but if one rolls a 1 or 2 on his damage save, and bam...fight over.

Granted you can use Hero Points to mitigate that somewhat, but it'd be nice if the damage system somehow emphasized 'deterioration over time' better. I realize that repeated hits degrade your damage save bonus, but what I mean is the vulnerability one has to getting a bad roll that turns a cool knock-down drag-out brawl into an anticlimax.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

Behold the sexiness of Mutants and Masterminds 3rd Edition - DC Adventures Hero's Handbook

dc_hero.jpg

This will be published as a stand alone game but the rules are identical in every way to M&M 3rd Ed. making it (and its statted characters) fully compatible with the new version of the game.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I heard that Superman is only PL15 in these rules.

It makes me curious as to what the power curve is, as PL 15 in 2nd Ed, while significantly above 'normal' heroes, isn't really the epic power one generally associates with DC's heaviest hitter...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I assume that you are referring to the PL caps for damage/toughness and such rather than the PL:PP ratio which usually flies right out the window with NPC write ups.

I know that they are trying to write up the heroes and villains in such a way that the "classic core" of the character is there. Superman has been all over the map in terms of power from back when he showed up and didn't fly and was strong but not epically so to the other extreme where he could move planets and snuff stars.

Its also hard to tell what PL 15 will mean without first knowing what the baseline will be. If the "just human" characters like Green Arrow, Batman, Joker, etc. only end up statted at PL 8 then 15 for Superman may work out. Time will tell and if I can predict anything accurately is is that in the end fans will argue about the stats of the characters regardless.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
  • 1 month later...

I've had the digital version for close to a month now. Haven't played with the new rules yet (but then they are pretty much the old rules as far as combat) but I've worked up character's for a game I'm going to run. In general pricing has been adjusted so that IMO at the same number of points character's are going to be a little less capable and thus have more to look forward to with PPs.

The biggest changes (actual changes not terminology changes) are the Attributes (8 now), Skills (only ~12 now), and power building. Powers are no longer even a little bit prebuilt, instead they take the Ultimate Power approach of giving you a bunch of effects and allow you to build the powers you want by combining effects, modifiers, and descriptors. This is nothing new but it see it in the core rules is a nice change.

The effects list has some big changes as well. Gone are the unpteen stun/dazzle/paralyze/confuse/ect powers and instead there is a single "Affliction" effect with a myriad of well balance choices for the 3 possible levels of failure. Want to paralyze somebody with Atemi pressure points? Affliction (fortitude save) (hindered/ immobile/helpless) .. translation 1/2 speed, 0 speed, defenseless and immobile. Want to blind somebody with a psychic attach? Affliction (Will save) (impaired/disabled/unaware) ... translation -2 to checks with that sense, -5 to checks, completely unable to use that sense. Mind Control? Affliction (Will) (Dazed/Compelled/Controlled), etc etc its the most drastic change to the game but also hailed as one of the best.

The DC veneer is just that, its clearly a set of generic rules that the DC artwork and polish has been added to with the only real DC content being a chapter on the DC Universe(s) and another with 28 of the biggest heroes and villains. Superman, Darkseid, Bats, the Joker, etc. All were chosen because of their star status (I barely read DC and I think only 1 of the villains was foreign to me and none of the heroes), but equally all show off the diverse nature of the PL system (ranging from a PL 8 Robin to the PL 16 Darkseid) as well as the various ways that the system can make characters. Hell just seeing how very different Robin (PL 8), Nightwing (PL 10), and Batman (PL 12) are is a nice touch to show you how diverse the same basic character archetype can be within the rules.

Overall I'd say its largely a step in the right direction and an improvement in general. The nitpicks I have are either minor (they still haven't made Charisma/Presence point balanced) or easily fixed (I can slow healing times down easily enough and break the skills up or require specializations), and the positive changes are significant to say the least.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

Had a chance to play a little last week. I was teaching new people so it was hardly a stress test for the rules but it by the end of the afternoon they clearly had a grasp on how things worked so teach-ability isn't a problem.

Overall I like that there is a clearly defined degrees of success and failure in DCA/3E defined by increments of 5 from the DC. This works well and when you apply a circumstance modifier (now limited to +2 or +5 for minor/major advantages and disads) you know that you are are basically adding/removing half or 1 full degree. Combat runs quickly, as it did in 2nd ed. The new dazed condition hurts a great deal less than 2E stunned and makes for a more fun combat as you can't suffer from "stun lock". The 1 time free recovery maneuver is also nice as it encourages extra effort be used. This is especially true since fatigue is now only a speed reduction and imposes no other penalties. You can basically get 2 free stunts/extra efforts per combat which is nice.

Negative changes are the single damage track. Gone is the lethal/nonlethal split and I may house rule that back in some form. The other thing I don't care for is healing times. This is a matter of taste and the fact that I don't run a lot of 4-color type supers games. Healing is automatic on a per minute basis with long term wounds being considered a complication (and thus garnering the wounded a HP). I'm sure this works for a Justice League game but it doesn't work for a vigilante/spec. ops. type game.

Overall I find 3E to be full of steps forward and only a few missteps.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 weeks later...
  • 3 months later...

I actually prefer the Impervious change. I always hated that a PC could render him/herself completely immune to even the max power level damage for their PL. This way lower PL bad guys still have a chance to hurt the good guys and the players will still have a chance to affect Impervious based NPC opponents.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In third edition they basically made Impervious only useful for people with Toughness shifts and Penetrating only useful for those with Attack Bonus shifts.

TBH It's a good change. You don't see people with Toughness +5 bouncing bullets off their abs, they reply on their dexterity and defenses. Likewise, you almost never see people who can pop tanks open like Budweiser cans having attacks that cut through armor, they instead rely on brute force to get the job done.

Impervious does the job it's meant to: it makes those who are supposed to be really tough, able to ignore the little people.

Penetrating does it's job as well: it provides a counter to impervious for concepts that need it.

In rare cases where a concept is such that a low toughness character is immune to damage it is almost always a specific form of damage and would best be shown via Immunity.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

A few months ago I ordered the paperback version of the 3rd Edition Mutants & Masterminds Hero's Handbook. At the time of my order it was supposed to be delivered in February. Then it was pushed back to the end of March. Last week I was notified that it would be shipping next week. And finally today I received notice that it would ship in the middle of July.

The PDF version is already available and according to Green Ronin's website the book is available at stores. Has anyone seen the paperback, non DC version?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Did you order from Amazon? Amazon has been known to be ... terrible, when it comes to dates. Physical product has been in players hands for about 1-2 weeks now for those who ordered direct from Green Ronin which means that retailers will be receiving and shipping accordingly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I noticed your "Never trust Amazon" post in that thread. I rarely purchase any gaming related books prior to launch so I never encounter problems.

I wish you could also get the PDF for an additional $5 other places.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Actually you can. If you talk to your FLGS they can sign up with GR and will be able to see you the pre-orders and PDFs through their brick & mortar. You get a code to be entered online for the PDF.

I'll see if I can find a link to their site for more info.

Edit: I should also clarify: My "never trust amazon" is really in regards to release dates. Amazon has been known to make up dates outright in order to have something listed for an item. A practice which has ended up generating a lot of posts with angry tone on the ATT forums when those dates come and go even though GR never gave a date to anybody.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very cool.

I'm not entirely sure why I am even getting the book. I bought first and second edition and haven't played either of them. Perhaps it is just because I run a RPG site and want to know how the games on here work. Or perhaps I am just delusional and think that if I buy it I may play it at some point.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Heh, I know the feeling. When they went out of business, I bought up every Star Wars d6 suppliment they still had in stock, because I figured I would run a game someday, and because it's freakin Star Wars and their going out of business sale was so fantastically cheap. Still haven't ever run a game and now the there is the new stuff out so I probably never will run d6, but damn it, I've still got them! wink

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I get frustrated with books at the actual game table. Unless you break their spines they don't lie flat. As a result I don't buy books anymore. I buy the PDF and either use a laptop or, if I think I want a dead-tree version, I create my own "book" at work and bind it in a standard 3 ring binder or, if I have access, a comb binder. Much like the spiral bound Æon/Trinity book they lie flat, and with a 3-ring version I can remove pages to hand to people and when errata come out I can replace pages as need be.

I'm not sure this is economic or feasible for everybody but if I'm gonna work unpaid overtime I'll take advantage of unofficial side benefits like this.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: Ryan Jackson
I get frustrated with books at the actual game table. Unless you break their spines they don't lie flat. As a result I don't buy books anymore. I buy the PDF and either use a laptop or, if I think I want a dead-tree version, I create my own "book" at work and bind it in a standard 3 ring binder or, if I have access, a comb binder. Much like the spiral bound Æon/Trinity book they lie flat, and with a 3-ring version I can remove pages to hand to people and when errata come out I can replace pages as need be.

I'm not sure this is economic or feasible for everybody but if I'm gonna work unpaid overtime I'll take advantage of unofficial side benefits like this.


I had spiral bound books made of the Abby fanbooks, because I've always liked books better than ebooks. Purely on the basis that I can navigate them much faster than a pdf.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: Damon OOC
I had spiral bound books made of the Abby fanbooks, because I've always liked books better than ebooks. Purely on the basis that I can navigate them much faster than a pdf.


Having a full version of Adobe Acrobat at work lends me the capability of creating my own bookmarks on my PDFs. If it weren't for that I would agree with you whole-heartedly

Edit: and yes I realize it sounds like I'm bragging but really just stating truthisms
Link to comment
Share on other sites

.pdf copies that you can actually search, as opposed to just scans, I would have to disagree with you on that. Especially when you either know generally what part of the book you're going to (and can use the slider bar on the side to get to that general area) or it has good bookmarks.

Otherwise, agreed, completely and totally.

But for me, personally, it's about 6 of one or a 1/2 dozen of another, especially when you have lots of sourcebooks (such as for my ED game). You might be able to flip through quicker with a book, but first you have to find that book, which may or may not include going to your stash. The .pdf's are centrally located on my netbook, so I can peruse any of them at a moments notice, and I can have them all open with only a modicum of difficulty in trying to find the specific one I want again.

So, while I lean towards the electronic version (especially the good ones), hard copies are good too. They'll never loose their place, in my opinion.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

Green Ronin released a Free Threat Report last week: Talona

The Threat Reports are a weekly release (every Wednesday) costing $0.99 and featuring a villainous NPC for use with the third edition of the game. Some of the 18 Threat Reports thus far have also featured small sidebars of additional rules suggestions and expansions.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If I could buy them in a bundle I'd get them all, but unfortunately the way they are available makes the charges more expensive than the product itself.

I heard you mentioned something about them thinking to put them all into one item that can be bought in a bundle? That would make it more attractive for me, since it is just one amount they can charge. Alternatively it would make things much easier if they accepted Euro as currency wink

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...